Play "Shouldn't Matter, But It Does" by John Mayer

In this guitar lesson, we'll learn how to play the chords and rhythm of Shouldn't Matter, But It Does from John Mayer's amazing Sob Rock album. This song is great to explore on the acoustic guitar, and we'll have a lot of fun learning it.

💡 Learn faster with JustinGuitarTabs! :) Get chords + lyrics and verified Tabs to follow along with my song lessons. Free trial here!

Ready? Now let's get stuck in!

Unpacking the Verse's Chord Progression

Let's kick things off by peeling back the layers of the verse chord progression. This progression is the song's backbone, giving it its distinct sound and feel. The sequence is E, G# minor, C# minor, and A add9. This sequence creates a rich, layered sound that forms the song's foundation.

The progression starts on the E chord, setting the song's tone. From there, we transition into the G# minor. After that, we move into the C# minor, and finally, we round off the progression with the A add9 chord. This chord progression flows beautifully and is repeated throughout the verses, giving the song its signature sound.

But here's where things get even more interesting: John Mayer introduces an unexpected 3/4 bar. This subtle change might initially go unnoticed, but it adds an intriguing rhythmic twist to the song. These kinds of details make Mayer's songwriting unique and captivating.

Exploring the Chorus

After the verses, we arrive at the chorus, where some fresh chords enter the spotlight. Here, we're introduced to an A chord, an E chord with a G# bass, a C# minor, and a B chord. These new chords add a new layer of complexity and interest to the song, further enriching its harmonic canvas.

The transition from the A chord to the E chord with a G# bass is particularly noteworthy, creating a beautiful melodic movement that really stands out. This transition is followed by the C# minor and the B chord, rounding off the chorus.

The Rhythm: The Heart of the Song

Now, let's talk about rhythm. The rhythm is the heartbeat of Shouldn't Matter, But It Does, driving the song forward and giving it its groove. It's not overly complicated, but it does require you to keep your strumming consistent.

The rhythm has a down-up-down-up pattern, which is a good starting point. But keep in mind that the rhythm isn't rigid. Feel free to loosen up and put your spin on it. The key is to keep your strumming hand moving consistently. This consistent movement is what gives the song its groove and flow.

Wrapping Up

And that's a wrap on the chords and rhythm of Shouldn't Matter, But It Does by John Mayer. This song is a beautiful blend of intriguing chord progressions and rhythmic subtleties, making it a joy to play on the guitar.

I hope you've enjoyed this journey through the song as much as I have. Remember, learning a new song is all about taking it step by step and enjoying the process. So, don't rush. Take your time to feel the music and let it flow from your fingers.

Ready to dive in and master Shouldn't Matter, But It Does on your guitar? Check out the video, and let's get started! Remember, we're here with you every step of the way, so grab your guitar, and let's make some music together!

👉 Want to learn more? JustinGuitar Courses are mostly free!